Law firm awards are everywhere: plaques in the lobby, badges in the website footer, a line under every attorney's name. Some of them reflect a real selection process and mean something to the people reading them. Others arrive by email with an invoice attached. This guide covers the main kinds of lawyer awards, how to tell an earned honor from a paid badge, how to use an award in your marketing, and the advertising rules that apply.
The main kinds of law firm awards
- Peer review ratings. Other lawyers and judges rate an attorney's legal ability and ethics. These tend to carry weight with referring lawyers.
- Selection lists. Publications that name a set of lawyers in a state or practice area each year, based on nominations, research and peer input.
- Bar association and community honors. Awards from a local bar, a trial lawyer association, a law school or a charity for service, leadership or pro bono work.
- Local "best of" lists. Newspaper or magazine reader polls. They mean more to a local consumer than to another lawyer.
- Client review badges. Ratings built from client reviews on directories and review sites. See legal directories.
- Verdict and settlement recognition. Lists of notable results. These are past results and come with the strictest advertising rules.
Earned honor or paid badge?
Some awards are open to anyone willing to pay for the plaque, the badge or the listing. They are not always worthless, but a client who looks one up and finds it was bought trusts the firm less, not more. Before you accept or advertise an award, ask:
- Is there a published methodology? A real award explains how people are nominated and chosen. If you cannot find it, that is the answer.
- Who did the choosing? Peers, judges, a research team or an editorial board is a different thing from "our staff reviewed your profile".
- Did you have to pay to be selected? Paying for an optional plaque after being chosen is different from paying to be chosen.
- How many lawyers get it? An award given to almost everyone who applies tells a client nothing.
- Would a client recognize it? If nobody outside the firm has heard of it, it is decoration, not proof.
An unsolicited email that says you have been selected and then asks for a fee is the clearest sign of a paid badge.
Which awards actually help you get cases
Awards matter most at the moment someone is choosing between two or three firms. An injured person comparing websites, or a lawyer deciding where to refer a case, looks for a reason to trust one name over another. A recognized, earned award is one such reason. It does not replace reviews, a clear website or a fast answer on the phone, and a wall of unknown badges can look like an attempt to cover for something.
- For referrals from other lawyers: peer review ratings and bar honors carry the most weight.
- For injured people searching online: client reviews and well known local recognition matter more. See law firm reputation management.
- For both: one or two awards people recognize beat a dozen they do not.
How to use awards in your marketing
- Put the award with the right person. Most awards go to an individual lawyer, not the firm. Show it on that attorney's page and in their bio. See law firm website content.
- Name it exactly and give the year. The full award name, the organization that gave it and the year it was given.
- Link to the source where the awarding body allows it, so a reader can check.
- Keep it current. Remove awards that have lapsed or are many years old.
- Announce new ones. A short news post or release works well for a real honor. See law firm press release.
- Use badges where the awarding body permits. Many restrict how their logo can be used. Follow their rules.
Stay inside the advertising rules
An award on your website, in an ad or on a brochure is a communication about your services, so the lawyer advertising rules apply. Under the ABA Model Rules, Rule 7.1 bars false or misleading communications, and the comments explain that a truthful statement can still mislead if it creates unjustified expectations or compares your services with other lawyers' in a way that cannot be backed up. Rule 7.2 limits calling yourself a certified specialist. Check your state's version, because states differ.
- Do not describe an award as if it makes you "the best" or guarantees a result.
- Identify the awarding organization and, where your state requires it, how the award was chosen.
- Some states require a specific disclaimer next to awards, ratings or comparative claims. Check yours before you publish.
- Do not let an award imply a specialty certification you do not hold.
- Treat verdict and settlement awards as past results and follow your state's past results disclaimer rules. See law firm testimonials.
For the wider picture, see lawyer advertising.
Make sure the phone gets answered
An award earns you a second look, not a client. The person who picks your firm because of it will call, often outside office hours, and the impression you made disappears if that call goes to voicemail. See personal injury intake.
The short version
Pursue and display awards that have a published methodology, are chosen by peers or an independent process, and that clients or referring lawyers recognize. Skip the ones you are asked to pay for to be chosen. Show each award with the right lawyer, by its full name and year, and check your state's advertising rules before it goes on your website, in an ad or on paper.
Ready to Turn Reputation Into Cases?
Legal Leadz AI delivers exclusive injury leads state by state, each to one firm. Tell us your states, case types and intake hours, and we will help you plan volume your team can answer live.
Get My Free Market Analysis →