A contingency fee agreement is the contract that lets an injury firm take a case without charging the client up front. The firm is paid a share of whatever it recovers, and nothing for its time if there is no recovery. It is the most important document a new client signs, and the one most likely to cause trouble later if it is vague. This guide covers what the agreement must say, how expenses should be handled, and the ethics rules every firm should check against its own state's version.

What the ethics rules require

ABA Model Rule 1.5(c) sets the baseline for contingency fees. Under the model rule, the agreement must:

  • be in writing and signed by the client;
  • state the method by which the fee is determined, including the percentage that applies if the case settles, goes to trial or is appealed;
  • state which litigation and other expenses will be deducted from the recovery;
  • say whether those expenses are deducted before or after the fee is calculated;
  • clearly tell the client about any expenses they will be liable for whether or not they win.

When the case ends, the same rule requires a written statement to the client showing the outcome and, if there is a recovery, how the money was divided. Check your state's version of the rule, because many states add to it.

The fee must still be reasonable

A signed agreement does not make any fee acceptable. Rule 1.5(a) says a lawyer may not charge an unreasonable fee, and lists the factors that decide it, including the time and skill required, the fee customarily charged in the area for similar work, the results obtained and whether the fee is fixed or contingent. A contingency fee reflects the risk the firm takes on. Some types of claim, such as certain medical malpractice cases and claims against the federal government, carry fee limits set by statute, so check what applies before you quote a percentage.

Cases where a contingency fee is not allowed

Rule 1.5(d) prohibits contingency fees in two areas: domestic relations matters where the fee depends on securing a divorce or the amount of alimony, support or a property settlement, and criminal defense. Injury work is the classic contingency case, but a firm that takes other matters should make sure its standard agreement is never used for these.

Expenses: the part clients misunderstand

Most disputes over contingency fees are really disputes about costs. Filing fees, medical records, expert witnesses, depositions and travel can add up, and clients are often surprised by them at settlement. A clear agreement:

  • lists the kinds of expenses the firm may advance;
  • says whether expenses come off the recovery before or after the fee is calculated, because the order changes what the client takes home;
  • says what happens to advanced expenses if there is no recovery.

Rule 1.8(e) allows a lawyer to advance court costs and litigation expenses, and lets repayment depend on the outcome of the matter. Medical bills and liens are a separate question, covered in medical liens and medical records retrieval.

What else a good agreement covers

  • The scope of the engagement: which claim the firm is handling, against whom, and whether an appeal or a related claim is included.
  • Who else may work on the case: if another firm will share the fee, Rule 1.5(e) requires the client to agree to the arrangement, confirmed in writing, among other conditions. See attorney referral fees.
  • Settlement authority: that the decision to accept or reject an offer belongs to the client.
  • Ending the relationship: what happens if the client discharges the firm or the firm withdraws, and how any fee for work done would be handled under your state's law.
  • Communication: how the client will be kept informed, in line with Rule 1.4.

State rules add their own requirements

The model rule is a floor, not the full picture. Some states require specific wording, set fee schedules for certain cases or require a separate disclosure. Florida, for example, requires a signed statement of client's rights for contingency fee cases, and California's Business and Professions Code section 6147 requires most contingency agreements to state that the fee is not set by law and is negotiable. Have your template reviewed against your own state's rules and court rules, and review it again when they change.

Explain it, do not just collect a signature

A client who signs in a rush and is surprised at settlement is a complaint waiting to happen. Walk the client through the fee, the expenses and what they will owe if the case is lost, in plain language and in the language they are most comfortable with. Give them a copy. If you use e-signature, make sure the client can read the full agreement before signing and keeps their own copy afterwards. For what happens next, see law firm client onboarding.

Common mistakes

  • One fee stated for every outcome, with no mention of trial or appeal.
  • Silence on whether expenses come off before or after the fee.
  • No mention of what the client owes if there is no recovery.
  • An old template that predates a change in the state's rules.
  • No closing statement at the end of the case.

The short version

A contingency fee agreement must be in writing, signed by the client, and clear about the fee at each stage, the expenses and what the client owes if the case is lost. The fee must be reasonable, contingency fees are barred in criminal and certain family matters, and your state almost certainly adds rules of its own. Get the agreement right at intake and the conversation at settlement is easy. For the steps before the signature, see personal injury intake and law firm intake form.

Want More Cases to Sign?

Legal Leadz AI delivers exclusive injury leads state by state, each to one firm. Tell us your states, case types and intake hours, and we will help you plan volume your team can answer live.

Get My Free Market Analysis →